Skip to content
Platform comparison

Compare ecommerce platforms side by side.

Select the brands you are considering and compare their Ecom Rating, features, ease of use, value, support, pricing, business fit and user feedback using the same data published in our company reviews.

01 · Ratings See where the score difference comes from.

Overall rating is shown alongside Features, Ease of Use, Value and Support.

02 · Cost Compare pricing in context.

Starting price sits next to business fit instead of being treated as an isolated number.

03 · Community User TrueScore remains separate.

Community feedback does not overwrite the editorial Ecom Rating.

04 · Detail Pros and cons come from the reviews.

Use the comparison to narrow the shortlist, then open the full review for deeper research.

Comparison builder

Choose your shortlist.

Search the existing ratings database, select at least two companies and build a live comparison. You can also copy a comparison link and return to the same group of brands later.

01

Choose brands

2 of 4 selected
03

Side-by-side comparison

LIVE FROM COMPANY CARDS
Highest Ecom Rating: Payhip

This is the highest editorial score among the brands currently selected. It is not a universal “best” label; business fit still matters.

8.7 /10
Selected brands

Gumroad

Digital Selling8.2 /10

Payhip

Digital Selling8.7 /10
Editorial ratings
Overall rating
8.2
8.7
Features
8.7
8.8
Ease of use
9.3
9.2
Value
7.4
9.5
Support
7.9
8.0
Business fit
Best for
Independent creators and small teams selling digital products, memberships and licensed software
Creators selling digital products with low fixed costs and simple pricing
Pricing / starting price
$0/mo; 10% + $0.50 per direct sale
Free $0/mo + 5% transaction fee
Category
Digital Selling
Digital Selling
User ratings
User TrueScore
3.5/5
★★★★★
3.3/5
★★★★★
Approved reviews
6
6
Editorial context
Short description
Gumroad is a creator-commerce platform combining digital delivery, memberships, tax handling, team permissions and collaborative selling, with transaction-based pricing and an unusually detailed creator payout system.
Payhip is a creator-commerce platform for selling digital downloads, courses, memberships and coaching, with feature-complete pricing, direct payment-processor payouts and built-in tax handling.
Pros
  • Unlimited team members can be added to one Gumroad account
  • Separate Admin, Marketing, Support and Accountant roles provide different permission levels
  • Financial and payout access can be restricted separately from marketing and product access
  • Collaborators can jointly manage individual products and receive an automatic share of every sale
  • Collaborator earnings are automatically credited to the collaborator's own Gumroad balance
  • Paid products priced above $0.99 can contain individual files up to 20 GB
  • There is no stated limit on the number of files that can be added to a paid product
  • Built-in license keys can support multi-seat software licenses
  • Multi-seat membership upgrades can charge customers a prorated amount immediately
  • Creators can choose daily, weekly, monthly or quarterly payout schedules when eligible
  • Creators can set their own payout threshold above the platform minimum
  • Payout reports can be exported with individual Gumroad fees and customer-level transaction data
  • All features are available on every pricing plan
  • Free plan includes unlimited products and unlimited revenue
  • No fixed monthly platform cost is required to start selling
  • Pricing tiers can be selected purely by transaction economics rather than feature access
  • Supports digital downloads, courses, memberships and coaching in one account
  • Payments are routed directly to the seller's connected payment processor
  • Supports 13 payment processors across multiple regions
  • Automatically handles digital EU and UK VAT by default
  • Handles US sales tax collection and remittance
  • Custom domains can be connected without upgrading to a higher feature tier
  • Built-in marketplace can provide an additional discovery channel
  • Digital product files can be up to 5GB
Cons
  • New creator accounts can remain under payout review until Gumroad has enough legitimate sales data
  • The initial account review can take approximately 1–3 weeks depending on sales and risk signals
  • Gumroad says a typical review may require roughly 3–4 legitimate sales and a balance above $100
  • Every eligible sale normally has at least a 7-day holding period before payout
  • The standard minimum payout balance is $100 and some countries have higher local thresholds
  • A chargeback rate above 1% automatically pauses payouts until the rate returns to 1% or below
  • Changing the payout country can in some cases require forfeiting the existing Gumroad balance
  • PayPal payouts used as the payout method carry a 2% processing fee
  • Daily payouts are restricted to eligible US creators with at least four previous payouts
  • Instant payouts are limited to eligible US creators and currently carry a 3% fee
  • A collaborator can receive no more than 50% of a product's revenue share
  • Adding a collaborator to a product removes existing affiliates from that product
  • Team management is not currently supported in Gumroad's mobile apps
  • Free products are limited to 250 MB of total uploaded content
  • The Free plan takes a 5% Payhip transaction fee on every sale
  • The Plus plan still charges a 2% Payhip transaction fee
  • Payment processor fees remain separate from Payhip fees
  • The platform is less flexible than a self-hosted WordPress commerce stack
  • Store design customization is more constrained than a fully developer-controlled website
  • Advanced businesses may outgrow the built-in commerce architecture
  • The marketplace does not provide automatic exposure to every new seller
  • Marketplace eligibility requires prior sales and account review
  • Individual marketplace products must still be approved
  • Seller support is primarily email-based with no phone support
  • Payment-account restrictions may need to be resolved with the external payment processor
  • Moving to paid plans reduces fees rather than unlocking a substantially broader feature set
Full review
Read Gumroad review →
Read Payhip review →
How to read the comparison

A higher score is only one part of the decision.

The comparison tool highlights stronger numeric scores, but the highest-rated platform is not automatically the best choice for every business. A lower-scoring platform can still be the better fit when its pricing model, workflow or target user matches your requirements more closely.
Ecom Rating
Use it as the broad editorial signal.

It summarizes the platform assessment on a 10-point scale and provides the starting point for comparison.

Breakdown
Look for the reason behind the total.

Features, Ease of Use, Value and Support show where one platform gains or loses ground against another.

Best For
Check whether the product is built around your use case.

A platform designed for creators, B2B merchants or multi-store businesses should not be judged only by the same headline score.

User TrueScore
Use community ratings as a second perspective.

Approved user feedback is displayed separately from the editorial score so the two signals remain easy to distinguish.

Comparison FAQ

Before you choose.

The tool is designed for shortlisting rather than declaring one universal winner. Compare the numbers, then use the individual reviews to investigate the differences that matter to your business.

How many ecommerce platforms can I compare at once?
You can compare between two and four company cards at the same time. Keeping the group small makes the detailed rating, pricing, pros and cons rows easier to evaluate side by side.
Are the comparison scores separate from the company reviews?
No. The comparison plugin reads the same company-card data used throughout Ecom Ratings. If an editorial rating or other company field is updated, the comparison reflects the updated card rather than maintaining a second independent score.
Does the highest Ecom Rating mean that platform is always the best choice?
No. The Ecom Rating is a broad editorial assessment. Pricing, category, business fit and the individual Features, Ease of Use, Value and Support scores may make another platform a stronger match for a specific use case.
What is the difference between Ecom Rating and User TrueScore?
Ecom Rating is the site’s editorial score on a 10-point scale. User TrueScore is a separate community rating based on approved user reviews and uses a 5-star scale.
Can I send someone a link to a specific comparison?
Yes. After selecting at least two brands, use the comparison tool’s “Copy comparison link” button. The selected company slugs are stored in the URL so the same comparison can be reopened directly.
Want to browse before comparing? Open the full ratings directory and filter the available company reviews first.
View all platform ratings →